THE PLAYERS LAB | COACHING REFLECTIONS
Are We Coaching Kids or Making Their Decisions for Them?
There's something I often say to parents when we're talking about junior basketball.
Every time you yell an instruction from the sideline, you rob that kid of an opportunity to develop in that moment because you've made the decision for them.
It's something I genuinely believe and it plays a big part in how I approach coaching.
Think about how often we hear instructions being yelled during a junior basketball game.
"Pass it!"
"Shoot!"
"Drive!"
"Move!"
And most of the time, everyone means well. Coaches want to help their players and parents want to see their kids succeed.
But I often wonder whether we're actually helping them learn.
If a kid passes the ball because someone on the sideline told them to, did they recognise the opportunity themselves? Did they read the defence? Did they make that decision?
Or did someone else make it for them?
How I Approach It
I'm not suggesting coaches should stand on the sideline and say nothing. I certainly don't.
There are times when I'll give instructions during play, particularly when we're introducing something new, reinforcing something we've been working on or when an aspect of our game really isn't going to plan.
But generally, I try to use trigger words rather than constantly directing individual players.
For example, I might call out "split" to remind the boys to recognise their defensive positioning.
Or "basket" when we need someone getting back to protect the ring in transition.
Those words are reminders of concepts we've already worked on. The players still need to recognise what's happening and respond.
What I try to avoid is constantly telling individual players exactly where to stand, when to pass or what decision to make.
Because if I'm making those decisions for them, what are they actually learning?
Sometimes the Conversation Matters More Than the Possession
When I want to give a player specific feedback, I'll usually wait for a dead ball and call them over for a quick chat.
I might ask what they saw, what they were trying to do or whether they recognised another option.
But there are also times when I won't wait.
If I can see a kid's confidence dropping quickly or there's something I think they really need to hear, I'll call them over during live play.
And if that means we're playing offence or defence with four players for ten seconds, I'm perfectly comfortable with that.
Because sometimes the conversation I'm having with that kid is more important than the next possession.
That moment might be exactly what they need to settle themselves, regain some confidence or understand something that's been troubling them.
For me, that's coaching too.
Let Them Play
One of the things I enjoy most about coaching is watching a player recognise something we've been working on and make the decision themselves.
Not because I've yelled it from the sideline.
Not because they've looked towards the bench waiting for instructions.
But because they've seen it, understood it and acted on it.
They won't always get it right. Sometimes they'll make a completely different decision from the one I would've made.
And that's fine.
Those moments give us something to talk about, something to learn from and something to try again.
I'd much rather have a player make the wrong decision for themselves and learn from it than make the right decision simply because I told them what to do.
Something Worth Thinking About
I'm not suggesting my way is the only way to coach. I'm constantly learning and reflecting on my own approach.
And I understand how easy it is to get caught up in a game, especially when things aren't going well.
But the next time you're watching junior basketball, whether you're a coach or a parent, pay attention to how often we're making decisions for the kids.
Then ask yourself a question.
Are we helping them learn to play the game, or are we playing it for them?
THE PLAYERS LAB
We don't just teach skills. We teach players how to PLAY.
PLAY. THINK. DEVELOP.
FIND A PLACE